Average Workers’ Comp Settlement For Surgery (with Examples)

Last updated:
Published by CalculateMyCase.com

The average workers’ comp settlement for claims that involve surgery is $85,345 and the median is $45,000. This is based on data from 71 workers’ compensation settlements that required surgery and were recorded by Thomson Reuters in the last 5 years (between 2019 and 2024). Factors that affect settlement value include injury severity, average weekly wage of worker, level of impairment or disability, and total medical expenses.

Table of Contents
Average workers' comp settlement amount for surgery (2024 chart)
Average workers’ comp settlement amount for surgery (2024 chart)

Settlement data is as follows:

  • Median settlement amount: $45,000 – The median settlement amount is a measure of central tendency, which may more accurately reflect the typical payout for a workers’ compensation claim that involves surgery due to not being heavily skewed by extremely high or low settlement values (unlike the average calculation).
  • Average settlement amount: $85,345 – The average settlement is calculated as a sum of all workers’ compensation settlements that included surgeries, which is then divided by the total number of cases (71 total cases).
  • Highest settlement amount: $1,207,500 – An individual was severely and permanently injured while working as a paving foreman. The individual was knocked to the pavement and run over by an asphalt transfer vehicle backing up within a roadway closure. The transfer truck was owned by a transportation company and operated by its employee. The transportation company was one of several sub-haulers hired by another hauling company, with the workers’ compensation carrier also involved. The individual contended that the driver was negligent in operating the truck and striking them because the driver failed to maintain a proper lookout for pedestrian workers in the area and the backup alarm did not sound. The driver denied these claims, and there was conflicting witness evidence regarding whether the backup alarm was sounding. The individual also alleged that the hauling company was vicariously liable for the negligence of the independent contractor and its employee-driver under a non-delegable duty of care doctrine. The company’s safety director stated that the individual failed to follow safety rules, including watching out for co-workers’ and their own safety and maintaining eye contact with equipment operators. The individual sustained complex fractures and dislocation of the right tibia and fibula, multiple complex foot fractures, and spine injuries. They underwent surgery for an open reduction and internal fixation of the right ankle, fasciotomy of the right leg and foot, application of a wound vacuum to the leg and foot, and application of a short leg splint. Later, they had an outpatient surgery to remove scar tissue and bone spurring, repair a torn ligament, and remove broken surgical hardware from the fibular bone. The individual claimed they would require future ankle fusion surgery.
  • Lowest settlement amount: $3,058 – The individual and their employer sought approval for a worker’s compensation settlement. During an observation training tour at work, the individual tripped and suffered a spine injury and an ankle injury. As a result of the accident, the individual underwent open internal fixation surgery on their ankle. Post-surgery, the individual reached maximum medical improvement, was cleared to return to full duty without restrictions, and was assigned impairment ratings of 10% to the foot, 7% to the lower extremity, and 3% to the whole body. The individual returned to full duty work, and the parties settled the worker’s compensation claim based on an impairment rating of 10% to the foot.

⚠️ Injured? See if you have a case… Start Quiz →

Note: Settlement data is intended for informational purposes only, and should not be interpreted as a guaranteed settlement amount for your workers’ comp case. If you are eligible to recover compensation, your settlement may be higher or lower than the amount provided above depending on the various circumstances and factors of your case

Workers’ Compensation Payout Charts

Data from the settlement charts below is sourced from the National Council on Compensation Insurance’s (NCCI) Workers Compensation Statistical Plan database, which reflects claim payouts on workers’ comp insurance policies in states where NCCI collects data.

Average workers' compensation payout by body part
Workers' comp settlement chart (payout by body part)
Workers’ comp settlement chart (average payout by body part)

The NCCI notes the following regarding the above injuries and corresponding settlement payouts specified by body part:

  • Head/CNS (a): Includes all injuries related to the central nervous system
  • Hip/thigh/pelvis (b): Includes injuries related to the sacrum and coccyx
  • Face (c): Includes teeth, mouth, and eye injuries

Furthermore, it’s important to note that the NCCI does not guarantee 100% accuracy of the data, and is not responsible for it’s use on 3rd party sites.

Workers' comp settlement chart (payout by cause of injury)
Workers’ comp settlement chart (average payout by cause of injury)

Consulting with a workers’ compensation attorney can help clarify the compensation you may be entitled to receiving following an workplace injury, and take the necessary legal actions to help you maximize your compensation.

⚖️ Find out if you’re eligible to recover compensation… Free Case Review →

Workers’ Comp Settlement Examples (with Surgery)

  • $24K settlement: An individual sustained a crush injury to the left arm, hand, and fingers while working. The individual underwent a left ring finger mid-amputation surgery. They claimed permanent disability due to the accident. The treating doctor placed the individual at maximum medical improvement and released them to return to work with restrictions, including a 20-pound lifting limit and limits on pushing, pulling, and reaching. The individual was assigned a 70% medical impairment rating for the index finger or 14% for the hand. A second surgery, a carpal tunnel release, was performed, and the individual was later assigned a 16% medical impairment rating to the upper extremity. They were placed in the medium work category, with a lifting limit of up to 30 pounds. The individual’s average weekly wage at the time of the accident was $2,168.58.
  • $60K settlement: An individual filed a worker’s compensation claim after tripping and falling at work, resulting in a broken left femur and left shoulder injury, which required surgery. The individual reached maximum medical improvement and was given an impairment rating of 10% to the body as a whole. Their average weekly wage was $219.20.
  • $75K settlement: An individual filed a Jones Act complaint after suffering a lower back disc herniation that required surgery while working aboard a cargo container ship, assisting with storing mooring lines. The complaint was against the employer and ship owner, alleging negligence, unseaworthiness, and failure to provide adequate care. It contended that the employer did not provide a safe working environment, proper training, sufficient crew, or adequate equipment, and required the individual to lift excessive weight. The employer denied liability and disputed the injury’s nature and extent, noting the individual worked for 22 days, 12 hours per day before reporting the injury.
  • $98K settlement: An individual filed a worker’s compensation claim after slipping and falling on a wet and icy roof while on a construction job, resulting in injuries to the neck, ulnar nerve, and lower back. The individual continued to work but sought emergency medical attention a week later. After being initially misdiagnosed with arthritis at a clinic, an MRI ordered by the primary care physician revealed neck injuries. The individual underwent surgery to place hardware in the neck, and another surgery several months later for further neck and back issues, which involved additional hardware placement. The treating doctor placed the individual at maximum medical improvement but continued to recommend light duty and further surgery. The individual had not worked since the accident and was approved for Social Security disability benefits. In their settlement petition, the parties acknowledged the individual’s neck and right arm injuries, noting an average weekly wage of $1,179.25, and the payment of temporary total disability and medical benefits by the insurer.
  • $144K settlement: An individual filed a worker’s compensation claim after experiencing a back injury while working. The individual was reaching for a part when their back twisted, causing pain in the back, right side, and hip, and numbness in the right leg. After another employee helped them stand, the individual reported the injury to a supervisor and was instructed to finish the work shift and then go home. By the end of the shift, the right leg was useless, requiring assistance to get into a vehicle. After being treated in a hospital, the individual went home but was virtually paralyzed several hours later, using a wheelchair for three months. The individual was placed on permanent work restrictions that could not be accommodated and was subsequently terminated. The individual continued to experience back pain radiating into the right hip and leg, along with occasional discomfort, numbness, and tingling in both legs. The company contended that the individual’s current medical condition was not related to the accident. The settlement included a monetary amount to close out any claims to future medical benefits.
  • $225K settlement: An individual pursued workers’ comp benefits after a malfunctioning truck pinned them to a post, resulting in knee injuries in addition to other bodily injuries that required surgery. The individual received a 27% impairment rating to the lower extremity, corresponding to an 11% impairment rating to the body as a whole. At the time of the injury, the individual’s average weekly wage was $999.76. The also settlement provided that the employer would be liable for future medical treatment and associated medical expenses.
  • $250K settlement: An individual injured their lower back while working, leading to a permanent disability claim. The individual’s average weekly wage at the time of injury was approximately $696. The parties reached a settlement in which the individual received weekly temporary total disability benefits from the date of the accident until reaching maximum medical improvement, with all medical expenses paid. The treating physicians indicated that the individual was suffering from failed low back surgery and chronic low back pain. The individual acknowledged in the settlement that they were unable to return to gainful employment and were physically unable to work.

⚖️ Find out if you’re eligible to recover compensation… Free Case Review →

Variables That Affect Workers’ Comp Settlement Value

Several variables can affect claim value and how workers’ comp settlements are calculated. This includes the extent of the injuries, the individual’s average weekly wage, the level of impairment or disability, medical expenses, and future medical needs. Here’s a breakdown of these variables with examples of how they may impact the settlement value

Extent of Injuries: The nature and extent of the injury significantly influence the compensation amount. More severe injuries typically result in higher compensation due to the increased impact on the individual’s ability to work and quality of life.

🖊️ Example: An individual with a minor wrist injury might receive $5,000 in compensation, while someone with a severe spine injury requiring multiple surgeries might receive $200,000 or more.

Average Weekly Wage (AWW): The individual’s average weekly wage before the injury is used to calculate benefits. Workers’ compensation usually pays a percentage of this wage during the disability period.

🖊️ Example: If the AWW is $1,000 and the compensation rate is 66.67%, the weekly benefit would be $666.67. Over 52 weeks, this amounts to approximately $34,666.84.

Level of Impairment or Disability: The degree of permanent impairment or disability affects the compensation. A higher impairment rating usually results in higher compensation.

🖊️ Example: An individual with a 10% impairment rating might receive $50,000, while someone with a 50% impairment rating might receive $250,000.

Medical Expenses & Treatment Costs: The cost of medical treatment, including surgeries, hospital stays, medications, and rehabilitation, is a significant factor in the settlement amount.

🖊️ Example: If medical expenses total $100,000, this amount is added to the settlement value. Future medical needs are also considered, potentially increasing the total compensation. If future medical costs are estimated at $50,000, this amount may be added to the settlement. For example, a $150,000 settlement could increase to $200,000 to cover future expenses

Temporary vs. Permanent Disability: Temporary disability benefits are paid during the recovery period, while permanent disability benefits are paid if the injury results in lasting impairment.

🖊️ Example: An individual receiving temporary disability benefits of $666.67 per week for 26 weeks would receive approximately $17,333.42. If they then receive permanent disability benefits, the total compensation might increase based on the impairment rating.

Vocational Rehab: If the injury prevents the individual from returning to their previous job, they might be entitled to vocational rehabilitation benefits to help them train for a new occupation.

🖊️ Example: If vocational training costs $10,000 and this is part of the settlement, the total value increases accordingly.

Settlement Structure: The type of settlement, whether lump-sum or structured, affects the total payout and how it’s distributed over time.

🖊️ Example: A lump-sum settlement of $100,000 might be preferred for immediate expenses, while a structured settlement could pay out $10,000 annually over 10 years, totaling $100,000 but distributed differently.

By considering these variables, the settlement value of a workers’ compensation case can be accurately assessed, ensuring fair compensation for the injured individual. It’s important to note that the variables above are just generalized examples that commonly affect claim value. Specific variables that affect your claim may be different depending on the unique circumstances of your case.

Understanding Workers’ Comp Benefits

Workers’ compensation benefits are designed to provide financial assistance and support to employees who suffer work-related injuries or illnesses. These benefits ensure that injured workers receive medical care, compensation for lost wages, and other necessary support without having to prove fault. Here’s a detailed explanation of the types of workers’ compensation benefits:

Medical Benefits: Covers all necessary and reasonable medical expenses related to the work injury or illness. This includes doctor visits, hospital stays, surgeries, medications, physical therapy, and any other required medical treatments.

🖊️ Example: If an employee injures their back while lifting heavy equipment, workers’ compensation would cover the cost of doctor visits, MRI scans, physical therapy, and any necessary surgeries.

Temporary Disability Benefits: Provides wage replacement for workers who are temporarily unable to work due to their injury or illness. These benefits are typically a percentage of the worker’s average weekly wage (AWW), often around 66.67%, and are paid until the worker can return to work or reaches maximum medical improvement (MMI).

🖊️ Example: An employee with an AWW of $900 would receive $600 per week in temporary disability benefits if they are unable to work due to their injury.

Permanent Disability Benefits: Compensates workers who suffer a permanent impairment or disability as a result of their work-related injury or illness. The amount and duration of these benefits depend on the severity of the disability and the worker’s impairment rating.

🖊️ Example: If an employee loses the use of a hand due to an accident, they may receive permanent disability benefits based on the extent of their impairment and the impact on their ability to work.

Vocational Rehabilitation Benefits: Provides services and support to help injured workers return to the workforce, either in their previous job or a new occupation. This can include job retraining, resume assistance, job placement services, and tuition for educational programs.

🖊️ Example: An employee who can no longer perform their previous job due to a back injury may receive vocational rehabilitation to train for a new career in a different field.

Permanent Partial Disability (PPD) Benefits: For workers who suffer a permanent disability that partially impairs their ability to work, PPD benefits provide compensation based on the degree of impairment and its impact on their earning capacity.

🖊️ Example: An employee who suffers a partial loss of vision in one eye due to a workplace accident might receive PPD benefits proportional to the extent of their vision loss and its effect on their job performance.

Permanent Total Disability (PTD) Benefits: For workers who are permanently and totally disabled, these benefits provide ongoing compensation for life or until they reach retirement age. PTD benefits are intended for individuals who can no longer work in any capacity due to their injury.

🖊️ Example: An employee who is paralyzed from the waist down after a fall at work might receive PTD benefits to compensate for their inability to ever return to work.

Death Benefits: Provides financial support to the dependents of a worker who dies as a result of a work-related injury or illness. Death benefits typically include funeral expenses and ongoing payments to the worker’s spouse, children, or other dependents.

🖊️ Example: If a worker dies in a construction accident, their spouse and children may receive death benefits to help cover living expenses and funeral costs.

Mileage Reimbursement: Covers the cost of travel to and from medical appointments related to the work injury. This can include mileage reimbursement for personal vehicle use or public transportation costs.

🖊️ Example: An employee who needs to travel 20 miles each way to see a specialist for their injury may receive mileage reimbursement for those trips.

Additional Legal Considerations For Workers’ Comp Claims

Several additional legal considerations can significantly affect a workers’ compensation claim, including the statute of limitations, pre-existing conditions, third-party claims, employer defenses, and the impact of an employee’s actions. Here’s an overview of these factors:

Statute of Limitations: The statute of limitations is the time limit within which an injured worker must file a workers’ compensation claim. This period varies by state but typically ranges from one to three years from the date of injury or the date when the injury was discovered.

🖊️ Example: If a worker fails to file a claim within the specified period, they may lose their right to benefits. For example, if the statute of limitations is two years and a worker files a claim two years and one month after the injury, the claim may be denied.

Pre-Existing Conditions: If an employee has a pre-existing medical condition that is aggravated or worsened by a work-related injury, it can complicate the claim.

🖊️ Example: The extent to which the pre-existing condition contributes to the disability can affect the benefits awarded. For instance, if a worker with a history of back problems suffers a new back injury at work, the benefits might be adjusted based on the pre-existing condition’s impact.

Third-Party Claims: In cases where a third party (someone other than the employer or a co-worker) is responsible for the injury, the worker may have a separate personal injury claim against that party in addition to the workers’ compensation claim.

🖊️ Example: Successful third-party claims can provide additional compensation, such as pain and suffering, which are not covered by workers’ compensation. For example, if a delivery driver is injured in a car accident caused by another driver, they can file a workers’ compensation claim and a personal injury lawsuit against the other driver.

Employer Defenses: Employers can raise certain defenses to deny or reduce workers’ compensation benefits, such as arguing that the injury was not work-related or resulted from employee misconduct.

🖊️ Example: If the employer successfully proves these defenses, the worker’s claim may be denied or the benefits reduced. For example, if an employer proves that the injury occurred while the employee was engaged in horseplay, the claim might be denied.

Statute of Limitations: The statute of limitations is the time limit within which an injured worker must file a workers’ compensation claim. This period varies by state but typically ranges from one to three years from the date of injury or the date when the injury was discovered.

🖊️ Example: If a worker fails to file a claim within the specified period, they may lose their right to benefits. For example, if the statute of limitations is two years and a worker files a claim two years and one month after the injury, the claim may be denied.

Injury Reporting Requirements: Most states require employees to report work-related injuries to their employers within a specific time frame, often within 30 days.

🖊️ Example: Failure to report the injury promptly can result in denial of the claim. For example, if an employee reports a back injury two months after it occurred, the employer might argue that the delay complicates determining whether the injury is work-related.

Choice of Medical Provider: In some states, the employer or their insurance carrier has the right to choose the medical provider who treats the injured worker.

🖊️ Example: If the employee seeks treatment from an unauthorized provider, they might be responsible for those medical bills. For instance, if a state requires the employer to choose the doctor and the employee goes to their own doctor instead, the workers’ compensation insurer may refuse to cover those expenses.

Independent Medical Examinations (IMEs): Employers or insurers may require injured workers to undergo an independent medical examination to verify the extent of the injury and the necessity of the treatment.

🖊️ Example: The results of the IME can influence the benefits awarded. If the IME doctor determines that the injury is not as severe as claimed, benefits might be reduced or terminated.

Return-to-Work Policies: Employers may have policies in place for returning injured employees to work, either in their previous role or in a modified or light-duty capacity.

🖊️ Example: Refusing a suitable light-duty position can result in reduced or terminated benefits. For example, if an employee refuses a light-duty job that accommodates their medical restrictions, they may no longer receive temporary disability benefits.

Fraud: Any fraudulent activity, such as exaggerating the severity of the injury or working while receiving disability benefits, can affect the claim.

🖊️ Example: Proven fraud can lead to denial of benefits, repayment of benefits received, and even criminal charges. For instance, if an employee is caught working another job while claiming total disability, they could face severe penalties.

Settlement Agreements: Settlements can resolve workers’ compensation claims without a hearing, but they often require the injured worker to waive certain rights, such as the right to future medical benefits.

🖊️ Example: The terms of the settlement agreement can significantly affect future compensation and medical care. For example, accepting a lump-sum settlement might mean the worker cannot claim additional benefits if their condition worsens.

These legal considerations can significantly impact the outcome of a workers’ compensation claim, and understanding them is crucial for navigating the claim process effectively.

It’s important to recognize that each workers’ compensation case is unique, and how much compensation you receive can vary based on many factors. A workers’ compensation attorney can help injured workers navigate the complex claims process, ensuring all paperwork is filed correctly and on time. They can also advocate on the worker’s behalf, negotiate settlements, and represent them in hearings or appeals to secure fair compensation for their injuries.

Getting started with your workers’ compensation claim is easy. Just request a free case evaluation online, and a legal team in our network will reach out to you regarding your case. Our network of attorneys includes a team of over 250+ legal professionals throughout the United States with over $1 billion recovered for clients, including those who have suffered work injuries that required surgery.

⚖️ All of our attorneys work on a contingency fee basis, meaning there are no upfront legal fees or costs — you only pay if you win.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

What type of workers compensation is the most common?

The most common type of workers’ compensation benefit is temporary disability benefits. This generally includes injuries such as sprains, fractures, back injuries, and repetitive strain injuries, which temporarily prevent the employee from performing their job duties but are expected to improve with treatment and time. These benefits provide wage replacement for employees who are temporarily unable to work due to a work-related injury or illness, covering a percentage of their average weekly wage until they can return to work or reach maximum medical improvement.

How long do I have to file a workers’ compensation claim?

The time limit to file a workers’ compensation claim, known as the statute of limitations, varies by state but typically ranges from one to three years from the date of the injury or when the injury was discovered. It’s crucial to report the injury to your employer promptly, often within 30 days, to ensure eligibility for benefits.

How long will it take to receive my workers’ comp benefits?

The time to receive workers’ comp benefits varies by state and the specifics of the case, but typically, initial benefits are paid within a few weeks after the claim is approved. Delays can occur if there are disputes or additional information is needed to process the claim.

What happens if my workers’ compensation claim is denied?

If your workers’ compensation claim is denied, you have the right to appeal the decision. This process usually involves filing a formal appeal with your state’s workers’ compensation board and may require attending a hearing where you can present evidence and argue your case. Consulting with a workers’ compensation attorney can help navigate the appeals process effectively.

About

We use settlement calculators to help individuals estimate how much compensation they may receive from their personal injury claim. We partner with law firms throughout the United States to help produce the most accurate results. Our content and calculators are created with the help of top-rated attorneys and legal professionals.

Find out if you're eligible to recover compensation.

Free Case Evaluation →

⚖️ All of our attorneys work on a contingency fee basis, meaning there are no upfront legal fees or costs — you only pay if you win.