Average Settlement For Dental Negligence – 2024 Data & Case Examples
The average settlement for dental negligence is $303,467 and the median settlement is $60,000, which better represents the typical payout for a negligence claim. This data is based on 19 dental malpractice cases recorded by Thomson Reuters within the last 5 years (between 2019 and 2024).
Table of Contents
Dental Negligence Settlement Examples
- $10K settlement (lowest): A minor reportedly suffered a superficial burn or abrasion on the chin after a dentist performed a pulpotomy, during which a chemical substance inadvertently came into contact with the skin. A claim was made for the injuries, and the defendant agreed to settle the claim.
- $30K settlement: A minor sustained a chemical burn on the cheek while receiving dental treatment. A lawsuit was filed on behalf of the minor, seeking compensation for disfigurement, permanent scarring, and pain and suffering. The guardian also sought compensation for medical expenses, lost wages, and loss of society and companionship due to the incident.
- $90K settlement: A minor sustained dental injuries when an incorrect tooth was extracted, specifically the upper right lateral incisor, during a procedure. Additionally, the extraction of a supernumerary upper front tooth was not performed, and other teeth, including the upper front teeth, were chipped. The minor’s guardian claimed that the dentist was negligent in extracting a healthy tooth, which necessitated further surgery and caused damage to other teeth.
- $141K settlement: A minor sustained a puncture injury to the right eye while having braces adjusted by an employee at an orthodontic clinic. The injury occurred when a wire was cut during the adjustment, leading to multiple surgeries for the individual. The claim centered around the alleged negligence in failing to provide or require eye protection during the procedure. The orthodontic clinic was also held vicariously liable for the actions of its employees, including the orthodontist and the non-party employee involved. The case was settled between the parties.
- $438K settlement: An individual underwent oral surgery for the extraction of a wisdom tooth and reportedly suffered a fractured jaw, along with damage to facial nerves, ligaments, and tendons. These injuries resulted in permanent conditions, including pain, numbness, loss of motion, and facial asymmetry. The individual claimed that the dental practice failed to inform them of the material risks associated with the surgery, the available alternatives, and the methods for reducing or minimizing these risks.
- $765K settlement: An individual, a minor, underwent a procedure for the extraction of all four wisdom teeth by an oral surgeon. During the surgery, three second molars were mistakenly removed before the wisdom teeth were extracted. This incident caused emotional distress for the individual’s parents. The claim involved allegations of negligence and failure to obtain informed consent regarding the removal of the second molars. The oral surgeon admitted to violating the standard of care and not obtaining informed consent but contested the extent of the damages. A total of $650,000 was awarded for noneconomic damages and $50,000 for economic damages, while the parents received $35,000 and $30,000, respectively.
- $999K settlement: A wrongful death and survival action was brought following the death of an individual who passed away three days after suffering cardiac arrest during oral surgery. The surgery involved the administration of general anesthesia by a surgeon who was part of an associated practice. The individual had a medical history that included a myocardial infarction, an implanted pacemaker, sleep apnea, and diabetes. The claim stated that the surgeon failed to order a pre-surgical workup and that the individual experienced immediate respiratory distress after the anesthesia was administered, which was not properly and timely addressed by the surgical team. The estate alleged negligence in failing to fully consider the individual’s medical history, not obtaining complete medical records or consulting with the individual’s treating doctors, not ordering a pre-surgical cardiac workup, and failing to properly monitor and respond to the individual’s condition during sedation. The defendants denied all allegations of negligence, maintaining that the care provided was appropriate and met medical standards. The case was settled, with the majority of the settlement allocated to the wrongful death claim and the remainder to the survival action. The individual was survived by their spouse.
- $1.4M settlement: A wrongful death case was brought after an individual with severe periodontitis suffered a severe brain injury due to respiratory and cardiac arrest during a dental procedure. The individual was given nitrous oxide and mepivacaine/Polocaine before the full extraction of 13 remaining teeth and two roots. After being resuscitated and taken to a hospital, the individual became unresponsive and later passed away in a nursing home from complications related to the brain injury several months later. The estate claimed that the dental practice failed to obtain a complete medical history, consult with the individual’s other healthcare providers, or obtain medical clearance and records before recommending the procedure. The estate also alleged negligence in recommending that the procedure be performed in one continuous session without fully considering the individual’s risk factors, which included a complex medical history of diabetes, high blood pressure, an enlarged heart, congestive heart failure, and morbid obesity. The defendant disputed these claims but agreed to a settlement. The individual was survived by three adult daughters.
- $2M settlement (highest): An individual was diagnosed with adenosquamous carcinoma, a rare and life-threatening form of cancer. Due to the severity of the condition, approximately one-third of the individual’s tongue was removed and replaced with a graft from their arm. The treatment also included chemotherapy, radiation therapy, a temporary tracheostomy, and a temporary feeding tube. While the individual is now able to eat, the process is challenging, and they have lost much of their ability to taste. The cancer had metastasized to the lymph nodes in the neck, which were subsequently removed. Regular massages of the lymphatic system in the neck are required as part of ongoing care. Due to the cancer’s advanced stage, the individual’s life expectancy is reduced, with a projected 30% chance of surviving five years. The individual had been receiving routine dental care from a dentist for several years, during which a lesion was noted on the underside of their tongue. Although a referral to an oral surgeon was suggested, the individual did not pursue it, and the dentist allegedly did not express significant concern. Over the years, the lesion was documented, with continued notations that the individual had not yet seen an oral surgeon. The dentist testified that they urged the individual on several occasions to see an oral surgeon for a biopsy, but the individual did not follow the recommendation. The individual, however, denied these conversations, asserting that as a cancer survivor, they would have sought further medical advice if any mention of a biopsy or possible cancer had been made. The lesion eventually grew and became painful, leading the individual to consult a primary care physician, who then referred them to an oncologist. Surgery was scheduled shortly thereafter.
⚖️ Find out if you’re eligible to recover compensation… Free Case Review →
Factors That Affect Dental Negligence Settlement Value
Several factors affect how medical negligence settlements are calculated. Each settlement factor is considered to determine the appropriate compensation for the plaintiff. Key settlement factors that affect settlement value are as follows:
1. Nature and Extent of Negligence: The degree to which the dentist’s actions (or inactions) deviated from the standard of care expected in the profession.
🖊️ Example: If a dentist negligently fails to diagnose a severe gum infection that later requires extensive surgery, the settlement might be higher due to the clear breach of standard care. Conversely, if the negligence is minor, such as a simple mistake that is quickly corrected, the settlement might be lower.
2. Severity of Injury: The seriousness of the injury caused by the dentist’s negligence, including whether it resulted in temporary discomfort or long-term disability.
🖊️ Example: A patient suffers permanent nerve damage from a negligent root canal procedure, leading to chronic pain and loss of sensation. This severe injury would likely result in a higher settlement compared to a case where the injury was temporary and resolved with minor treatment.
3. Medical Expenses: The cost of medical treatment required to address the injury caused by the negligence, including both past and future expenses.
🖊️ Example: If a dental negligence incident leads to a simple corrective procedure costing $500, the settlement would primarily cover those expenses. However, if the negligence causes complications requiring multiple surgeries and long-term care costing tens of thousands of dollars, the settlement would be much higher to cover these substantial medical costs.
4. Lost Wages: Compensation for the income lost due to time off work for recovery, or if the injury impacts the patient’s ability to work in the future.
🖊️ Example: A patient is unable to work for two weeks after a negligent dental procedure, losing $2,000 in wages. The settlement would include compensation for these lost wages. If the negligence results in long-term disability affecting the patient’s career, the settlement could be much higher to cover future lost earnings.
5. Pain and Suffering: Non-economic damages for the physical and emotional pain experienced due to the negligent act.
🖊️ Example: A patient endures severe pain and distress due to a botched tooth extraction that leads to a painful infection. The settlement would include compensation for this pain and suffering, potentially adding a significant amount to the overall award.
6. Loss of Quality of Life: Compensation for the impact on the patient’s ability to enjoy life as they did before the injury, including loss of enjoyment of daily activities.
🖊️ Example: A patient loses the ability to chew properly after a negligent dental procedure, significantly affecting their diet and overall enjoyment of food. The settlement would include compensation for this loss of quality of life, increasing the overall amount awarded.
7. Comparative Negligence: If the patient’s actions contributed to their injury, the settlement might be reduced based on their percentage of fault.
🖊️ Example: If a patient fails to follow post-operative care instructions and this contributes to an infection, the settlement might be reduced. For instance, if the patient is found to be 30% at fault, a $100,000 settlement would be reduced to $70,000.
8. Duration and Extent of Recovery: The length of time and the extent of recovery required due to the injury, including whether the patient fully recovers or suffers permanent effects.
🖊️ Example: If a patient recovers fully within a few weeks after treatment for a negligent dental injury, the settlement might be modest. However, if the patient requires years of treatment or never fully recovers, the settlement would likely be much higher to account for ongoing medical care and the prolonged impact on their life.
9. Impact on Future Earnings: If the injury affects the patient’s ability to earn a living, especially if it results in permanent disability or limits career opportunities.
🖊️ Example: A dental negligence incident leads to TMJ disorder, making it difficult for the patient, a public speaker, to perform their job. The settlement would include compensation for the reduced earning capacity and potential career change, significantly increasing the settlement amount.
10. Punitive Damages: Additional damages awarded in cases where the dentist’s actions were particularly reckless or egregious, meant to punish and deter similar behavior.
🖊️ Example: If a dentist knowingly performed a procedure they were not qualified for, resulting in serious injury to the patient, the court might award punitive damages. These damages would significantly increase the total settlement, especially in cases of gross negligence or intentional misconduct.
Common Types of Dental Negligence
Common types of dental malpractice typically include the following:
- Misdiagnosis or Delayed Diagnosis: Failure to diagnose or a delay in diagnosing a dental condition can lead to the condition worsening, requiring more extensive and invasive treatments.
- Failure to Obtain Informed Consent: Dentists are required to inform patients of the risks, benefits, and alternatives to any proposed treatment. Failure to do so can result in a claim if the patient suffers harm.
- Improper Treatment: This occurs when a dentist performs an incorrect or inappropriate procedure, or uses the wrong techniques, leading to injury or exacerbation of an existing condition.
- Surgical Errors: Mistakes during dental surgery, such as extracting the wrong tooth, nerve damage, or excessive anesthesia, can lead to severe complications and potential claims.
- Failure to Diagnose Oral Diseases: Dentists must be vigilant in diagnosing oral diseases such as oral cancer, periodontal disease, or infections. Failing to diagnose these conditions in a timely manner can have serious consequences for the patient.
- Medication Errors: Prescribing the wrong medication or dosage, or failing to review a patient’s medical history for potential drug interactions, can result in harm and be grounds for a malpractice claim.
- Anesthesia Complications: Incorrect administration of anesthesia can lead to serious complications, including allergic reactions, nerve damage, or in severe cases, death.
- Failure to Refer to a Specialist: If a patient’s condition requires specialized care, and the dentist fails to refer the patient to an appropriate specialist, this could be considered malpractice if the patient’s condition worsens.
- Inadequate Sterilization and Infection Control: Failure to properly sterilize instruments or maintain hygienic conditions can lead to infections, which could be grounds for a malpractice claim.
- Post-Operative Care Negligence: Failing to provide adequate post-operative care instructions or follow-up can lead to complications and may be considered malpractice if it results in harm to the patient.
Each of these scenarios can lead to significant injury or suffering for the patient and could form the basis of a dental malpractice lawsuit.
Common Injuries From Dental Negligence
Common injuries resulting from dental malpractice can vary in severity, but they often include:
- Nerve Damage: Nerve injuries, particularly to the trigeminal nerve, are common in dental malpractice cases. This can lead to chronic pain, numbness, tingling, or loss of sensation in the mouth, face, or jaw.
- Tooth Loss or Damage: Incorrect extractions, improper dental procedures, or failure to properly diagnose and treat a dental condition can result in the loss or damage of teeth.
- Infections: Poor sterilization practices, improper procedures, or failure to treat infections in a timely manner can lead to serious infections, including abscesses or systemic infections like sepsis.
- Damage to Adjacent Teeth: Improper technique during procedures such as extractions, fillings, or the placement of crowns or bridges can cause damage to surrounding teeth.
- Bone Damage: Errors in procedures like extractions, implants, or other oral surgeries can lead to bone damage or loss, particularly in the jaw.
- Temporomandibular Joint (TMJ) Disorders: Dental procedures that involve the jaw can sometimes cause or exacerbate TMJ disorders, leading to chronic jaw pain, headaches, and difficulty chewing or speaking.
- Anesthesia Complications: Improper administration of anesthesia can result in complications such as allergic reactions, nerve damage, or, in extreme cases, brain damage or death.
- Soft Tissue Injuries: Cuts, burns, or other injuries to the gums, tongue, lips, or inside of the cheeks can occur during dental procedures due to negligence.
- Chronic Pain: Various forms of dental malpractice can result in chronic pain conditions, including persistent facial pain, headaches, or jaw pain.
- Sinus Perforation: During certain procedures, particularly upper jaw surgeries or extractions, a dentist may accidentally perforate the sinus cavity, leading to sinus infections, pain, or other complications.
- Facial Disfigurement or Scarring: Incorrect surgical procedures or mishandling of dental tools can lead to permanent scarring or disfigurement of the face or mouth.
- Loss of Taste: Nerve damage during dental procedures can sometimes result in a loss or alteration of taste sensations.
These injuries can have significant and long-lasting impacts on a patient’s health, quality of life, and emotional well-being, often requiring additional treatments or surgeries to correct the damage.
Maximize Your Settlement With Help From A Dental Negligence Attorney
It’s important to understand the each dental negligence claim is unique, and the amount you may receive from a settlement cant vary based on many factors. Consulting with a dental malpractice attorney can help ensure that you receive a fair settlement.
Getting started with your dental negligence claim is easy. Just request a free case evaluation online, and a legal team in our network will reach out to you regarding your case. Our network of attorneys includes a team of over 250+ legal professionals throughout the United States with over $1 billion recovered for clients, including those who have suffered injuries as a result of dental negligence.
⚖️ All of our attorneys work on a contingency fee basis, meaning there are no upfront legal fees or costs — you only pay if you win.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
How long do I have to file a dental negligence claim?
The time limit to file a dental negligence claim, known as the statute of limitations, typically ranges from 1 to 3 years depending on the jurisdiction. It’s important to check the specific laws in your state or consult with a legal professional to determine the exact deadline applicable to your case. Some exceptions may apply, such as when the injury is discovered later.
What is the most common dental malpractice?
Tooth extractions are the most common source of dental malpractice claims, particularly when performed by general dentists. Examples of malpractice during tooth extraction include removing the wrong tooth, where a healthy tooth is mistakenly extracted; using excessive force, which can break the jawbone or cause other complications; fracturing the tooth, potentially leading to nerve damage or infection if fragments remain; and improperly recommending an extraction when alternative treatments may be more suitable.
How do I prove dental negligence?
To prove dental negligence, you must demonstrate that the dentist breached the standard of care by failing to provide treatment that a competent professional would have under similar circumstances. Additionally, you need to show that this breach directly caused your injury or worsened your condition, resulting in specific damages such as pain, suffering, or financial loss. Expert testimony is often required to establish both the standard of care and the connection between the dentist’s actions and your injury.
How long will my dental negligence claim take?
The duration of a dental negligence claim can vary widely, typically ranging from several months to a few years. Factors such as the complexity of the case, the need for expert testimony, and whether the claim is settled out of court or goes to trial all influence the timeline. Settlements usually resolve faster, while litigation can take significantly longer.
About
We use settlement calculators to help individuals estimate how much compensation they may receive from their personal injury claim. We partner with law firms throughout the United States to help produce the most accurate results. Our content and calculators are created with the help of top-rated attorneys and legal professionals.
⚖️ All of our attorneys work on a contingency fee basis, meaning there are no upfront legal fees or costs — you only pay if you win.
